
WASHINGTON — The $495 million sale of the shuttered Appleton prison to the U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) will be the subject of an early probe into Trump administration immigration policies when Democrats take control of the U.S. House and Senate in January.
The midterm election, which will result in the transfer of committee gavels from the GOP to Democrats in the next Congress, has lawmakers preparing to use their new authority — which includes the issuing of subpoenas.
Sen. Maggie Hassan, D-N.H., in line to become the next chair of the Senate Homeland Security Committee, has already put CoreCivic, the company that owned the Appleton prison, and DHS on notice that they are subject to an investigation.
Hassan has demanded that CoreCivic preserve all records and communications related to the Prairie Correctional Facility, the name of the former private prison in Appleton, “from January 1, 2025, to date and on an ongoing basis moving forward.”
“The Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee is investigating whether federal spending by the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) was subject to improper influence, corruption, or other violations of federal law,” Hassan said in a letter to CoreCivic.
At issue is the sale of the prison to the federal government in August for about $495 million — a vastly higher amount than CoreCivic was willing to accept for the facility from the state of Minnesota.
In an email in the spring of 2025 to the deputy commissioner of the Minnesota Department of Corrections, Safia Khan, CoreCivic said it was asked by the staff of the state House Public Safety Committee if it would be willing to sell the Appleton prison and at what price.
CoreCivic said it was very willing to sell its facility for $75 million “inclusive of the upgrades CoreCivic has identified would be needed to re-activate the facility.”
The state did not follow through on the purchase, however, because of budgetary constraints as well as workforce and transportation concerns related to the prison’s remote location in western Minnesota, a spokeswoman for the Department of Corrections said.
CoreCivic did not respond to a request for information. Neither did DHS, though the agency has sought to cast investigations into its immigration policy as politically motivated.

Built by the city of Appleton and purchased by CoreCivic in 1997, the facility once held state prisoners but was shut down in 2010 because of decreased demand.
Hassan has questioned why DHS paid more than six times the price CoreCivic had asked for the facility.
The company has a separate five-year contract to run the facility for DHS.
“The Department of Homeland Security spent $495 million on a prison that had recently been offered for sale for $75 million and then paid the seller to keep running the facility,” Hassan said in an email to MinnPost. “This deal appears to be an enormous waste of taxpayer dollars that could have been spent on lowering costs, and it comes as there are serious concerns about pay-to-play schemes and corruption at DHS.”
Hassan has asked DHS to “take all necessary steps to prevent the destruction, alteration, or loss, whether intentional or negligent, of any records, communications, or other information that may be relevant to this Congressional inquiry, including electronic information and associated metadata.”
“This preservation request encompasses all records concerning the facility’s acquisition, valuation, financing, operation, and any proposed or completed sale, including appraisals, offers, negotiations, contracts, due diligence, financial analyses, internal deliberations, and communications concerning the transaction,” Hassan wrote in her letter to DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin.
The probe into the sale of the Appleton prison, which has begun to accept immigrant detainees, is part of what is expected to be a sweeping investigation of President Donald Trump’s immigration policies by Democrats who will take control of both chambers of Congress in January.
Those Democrats have already expressed interest in probing allegations of misconduct by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) — including the shootings of Alex Pretti and Renee Good, the detention of lawful residents and citizens, and the deaths and reports of dismal conditions at immigration detention centers.
Democrats will also investigate alleged mishandling of contracts by then-Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem and the role of adviser Corey Lewandowski.
Last week, Lucibeth Mayberry, CoreCivic’s new chief executive officer, indicated that the company, which has signed multiple federal contracts with DHS and ICE this year, is aware the political winds have shifted. She asked ICE officials to speed up the signing of new contracts.
“We would urge the ICE administration to move quickly,” Mayberry said during the company’s latest earnings call. “They have a need for capacity. We have the capacity. There’s no reason to wait.”
Mayberry also said CoreCivic continues to have discussions with ICE about the potential acquisition of additional detention facilities owned by the company.
The post Dems to investigate whether sale price jump for Appleton prison signals corruption or lawbreaking appeared first on MinnPost.